Skip to content
Brightworks Network

A United Ireland Plebiscite Should Not Transform Into 'A Sequel to Brexit', Analysts Warn

A decade after the UK embarked on a hasty referendum that polarised the nation and triggered chaos, a warning is issued from beyond the Irish Sea: it may occur once more.

Authorities and citizens drifted into Brexit and the identical may happen with a national vote on a unified Ireland, initiating convulsions for which no one is equipped.

That represents the warning from two respected journalists from each side of the Irish border who have joined forces to examine the pros and cons of Northern Ireland departing the UK to form a different country with the Republic of Ireland.

Political Structures Ill-Equipped

Fintan O’Toole and The Northern Ireland editor, have found that the administrative systems in Ireland and Britain are woefully unprepared for a possibly tense and monumental referendum.

"The crucial insight of Brexit hasn't been learned, which is that stuff can come out of the blue and can gain traction rapidly," the commentator said. "I would suggest that the institutional structure of our islands remains highly fragile."

Book Publication Seeks to Stir Debate

The team have examined the governmental, economic and societal arguments for any governmental shift in a volume, The Case For and Against Unification, released by the Irish Royal Irish Academy.

They hope to stir debate on the issue with a tour of public talks that will lead them to Westminster soon.

"What concerns everyone, or must worry everybody, is the Brexit vote of 2016," said the analyst.

"We should prevent a referendum on a thumbs up-thumbs down, vague proposition whose implications have not been spelled out because then you find yourself with an highly divided society where people who have lost are not reconciled to defeat and the those successful don't know quite what it is that they have won."

Constitutional Provision

Under the Good Friday agreement, the Northern Ireland government minister must arrange a referendum on Irish unification if it is indicated that a most voters would approve.

Sinn Féin and other nationalists claim this point is looming, and a non-profit called pro-unification advocates has rallied support, but both governments and pro-UK factions minimise the prospect, resulting in ambiguity whether or when there could be a national vote.

Insufficient Substantive Discussion

Ideological statements supporting and opposing unification has masked the shortage of serious debate, said the journalist.

"People tend to be for or against the idea but the actual thinking which may surpass that to achieve it is mostly absent. A lot has occurred in academia but very few government figures or campaigners seek to involve themselves even with the essentials. To illustrate, what sort of state might be preferred? Centralised? Federal?"

Publication's Method

In the volume, no writer endorses unity or the current situation. Each composes two pieces that strive for impartiality in detailing the rationale for a united Ireland and the rationale against, marshalling financial and social data, previous instances and constitutional models.

Discussions range over identity markers, levies, medical care, elderly benefits, public liabilities and the risk of pro-UK militancy. The aim is to educate and provoke conversation.

"There is significant curiosity in the issue but there is still lacking a debate," commented the writer. "Debate suggests an acknowledgement of the concept that there could be valid points on each side."

Simultaneous Plebiscites

A referendum in Northern Ireland would also trigger one in the republic, where citizens report they favour unity but refuse greater financial contributions or implementing a different emblem to acknowledge unionists' British identity.

"Policymakers in Ireland must determine what the proposal from Irish nationalism is beyond just declaring: 'We desire a united Ireland and we welcome you'," stated the commentator.

Possibility of Referendum

The journalist considers a referendum in his era is possible and that it might occur abruptly. "You could have just a reckless or a ill-advised or a negligent government minister who states: 'We should proceed and settle the matter.'"

Both nationalists and unionists have credible, valid perspectives, he said. "One side will prevail on this issue and the other side will eventually be defeated but all factions has got something to acquire from the alternative viewpoints."

Request for More Extensive Debate

Westminster must engage with the debate, said O’Toole. "This involves the United Kingdom. It's a British issue equally as it is an Irish question."

About the author

Teresa Smith

Elena is a seasoned tech consultant with over a decade of experience in digital transformation and strategic innovation.

Brightworks Network

Type to search articles.